Monday, July 2, 2012

If It Saves One Child

Original Article

07/02/2012

By Shelly Stow

It would be difficult today to find a person who had no idea what the sex offender registry is. It would be equally difficult to find someone with only a passing interest who didn’t feel that it is a good thing to have. It started in most states as a law enforcement tool identifying repeat, sexually violent child predators. It now has an estimated 700,000 names (PDF) on it and encompasses acts as varied as consensual teen sex, taking and sending a photo of one’s own breasts, and rape. And even though many with much more than a passing interest, including most research studies and experts in the field, are pronouncing the shaming roster to be an ineffective tool in fighting sexual crime, the battle cry of its supporters still resounds whenever the subject comes up: “If it saves one child…!

If it saves one child….” Even though we cannot know if “it” has, that statement is responsible for the abuse and even death of many children.

There is no actual evidence that the registry has saved even one child; however, we do know that many, many thousands have had their lives made a living hell because of it. These are the children of those on the registry, some of whom committed violent crimes, but many, even most, who did not. All on the registry, with their families, are subject to the whims of local and state restrictions including, but by no means limited to, severe restrictions on where they may live; denial of access to libraries, parks and beaches with their children; and restrictions barring the registered parent from often even being within a 1000 feet of the school his child attends. Very recently a woman took the picture of a registrant that she printed from the Internet to the school where the registrant’s five-year-old son was a kindergarten student; she showed it around, warning children about this man. His little boy stood and cried. The registry doesn’t differentiate. It doesn’t make it clear to people who threaten, harass, and do physical violence to registrants, their property, and their families whether daddy raped someone or whether he had sex with mommy before they were married when she was a year too young or whether he looked at an illegal image on a computer or whether he was innocent and falsely accused. And, sadly, most don’t really care. The perception is that everyone on the registry has committed a serious crime and that most if not all offended against children. And if they have children of their own who are harmed, as so many have been and so many more will be, it is just collateral damage because the registry might—MIGHT—save one child.

If it saves one child….” Children themselves are registrants on sex offender registries. Nine years old is apparently the youngest at which children have been put on the registry (Delaware; Michigan). (1) Several states, including but not limited to Colorado, Delaware, Georgia, Kansas, Ohio, Michigan, and Texas, register children as sexual criminals at ages ten and eleven. By the time twelve is reached, it isn’t even a rarity. And the fifteen year old who is the child victim for having consensual sex with an eighteen year old partner becomes a predator and registered sex offender when his or her partner is fourteen. In Wisconsin last year a district attorney did everything he could, and bragged about it, to have a six year old prosecuted and targeted for sex offender registration for “playing doctor.”(2) Three year olds caught looking at and touching each other in a daycare bathroom were reported and investigated for “sexual fondling.”(3) Some of these children, after several years of being on the registry and treated as monsters, have committed suicide. The registry didn’t save any of these children; it destroyed them.

If it saves one child….” Children do need saving. According to the Justice Dept. and the CMEC, many thousands are sexually abused and molested every year. We pour everything into the registry, millions of dollars and uncountable hours. State after state has voiced complaints about the cost of keeping up with the ever-increasing expenses and strain on limited manpower hours to satisfy the requirements of the registry. The federal government, knowing this, has offered huge financial incentives (bribes) to states to bring them into federal registry compliance. However, this is futile; the registry is not the answer. Children aren’t sexually abused and molested by nameless, faceless people on the registry. They are abused and molested by their family members and acquaintances, by those they know and trust and love, by those they see and interact with on a daily basis, often by those they live with. By the most conservative estimates, this is true for 94 out of every 100 children who are molested. The latest figures from the Justice Department's Bureau of Juvenile Justice show these startling facts: for sexual crime against a child six or under, 58.7% is committed by family members, 39.7% by family acquaintances, and 1.8% by strangers; the registered sex offenders who are in that stranger pool are so few that it is virtually incalculable. As the age of the child increases, the figures alter, but only a little. The risk to children ages 12-17 is 94.3% from family and acquaintances, 5.7% from strangers, and, again, the percentage of registered offenders in the stranger pool is minuscule. Keeping the focus on those on the registry keeps us from dealing with these facts. It keeps us looking in another direction, and it leaves us nothing in the way of resources with which to deal with it.

If it saves one child,” isn’t good enough. Thousands, hundreds of thousands, need saving. When and how and with what will we save them?

Shelly Stow is a member of Reform Sex Offender Laws [RSOL] and Texas Voices, the Texas affiliate of National RSOL.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Government of Yukon Insurance Management entertainment Recovery Living Educational Toy Game Vardenafil 20mg Wedding Dresses socially Auto Care Association Expression Online Marketing WELLNESS CHAPMAN INSTITUTE Canadian Critical Care Timeshare Association IRDES Manners International Association Website Shopping Cart THE OFFICIAL BUSINESS MASSAGE IN BEIJING Contracts Online Business News Compass Scandi TV Fashion Protect Hairstyle Sports Education Quotes Cursoscyt2 Xceedid Corporation Technologie Systemy a Management Body and Fitness Design Buddies Homes I-Praca Education EDUCATION Training Primary School About Us Secondary School Technology Care Real Estate Lyndon State College PERSONAL WEBSITE Insurance or Credit Report IL Punto Web Design Auto Repair Service Business Plan design voice network LOANS MONTHLY PAYMENTS CREDIT kyweb Resources and Information Aca Allertor Industry The Story of Digital Health Cy-bocs Test Website Celebrity Bride Guide ARE WE EATING FISHY FOODS Health Website Fashion Foods Loans Monthly Website Shopping THE IACP Insurance Management Entertainment Recovery Living Technology buy viagra online real estate design network EDUCATION compass offices global kredit un vrai repas Amset IT Solutions mobile shopping summit Veolia Waste to Energy Plants Dexma Energy Management Results Online Hart Scientific website Preserve Giving Football Games 888 33travel Travel Time From International Payment Global Life Insurance quilpie shire council Travel Gate Tours Fashion Show Mall Stores FCRA Online Services Precision Strategy Perfect Plays Forex Trading Strategy Entertainment Music News Phoenix Publishing Fashion and Shopping Herbal Medicine Health Celebrations Fashion Designer Red Tree Custom Homes South Suburban Adoption Business Transformation Trading Craigconnects Voters Laws Information Technology Software Games Play Education Francesca's North The Real Housewives of New Jersey Cooking Food Grill Holmes School Design Fleisher's Meat AFR Heads for Sale Enyo JavaScript Application Framework Test fineart2buy.com as-canada.com cybergalleriet.com Homes Interior Design Fresh Wok Dedford
Fashion Fashion